Essay by Eric Worrall
h/t M; Wall Avenue Journal trashing claims the renewable power transition will convey down costs, or is even potential.
Why the Power Transition Will Fail
New report highlights the staggering price of inexperienced ‘delusions.’
By James Freeman
Aug. 26, 2022 4:50 pm ET…
In a brand new report due out subsequent week from the Manhattan Institute, Mark Mills takes on the “harmful delusion” of a world power transition that eliminates using fossil fuels. Surveying power markets and public coverage world wide, Mr. Mills asks readers to “think about that years of hypertrophied rhetoric and trillions of {dollars} of spending and subsidies on a transition haven’t considerably modified the power panorama.” He notes:
…
Claims that wind, photo voltaic, and [electrical vehicles] have reached price parity with conventional power sources or modes of transportation aren’t based mostly on proof. Even earlier than the most recent interval of rising power costs, Germany and Britain—each additional down the grid transition path than the U.S.— have seen common electrical energy charges rise 60%–110% over the previous 20 years. The identical sample is seen in Australia and Canada. It’s additionally obvious in U.S. states and areas the place mandates have resulted in grids with a better share of wind/photo voltaic power. Usually, general U.S. residential electrical energy prices rose over the previous 20 years. However these charges ought to have declined due to the collapse in the price of pure gasoline and coal—the 2 power sources that, collectively, equipped almost 70% of electrical energy in that interval. As an alternative, charges have been pushed larger due to elevated spending on the in any other case unneeded infrastructure required to transmit wind/solar-generated electrical energy, in addition to the elevated prices to maintain lights on throughout “droughts” of wind and solar that come from additionally maintaining typical energy crops accessible (like having an additional, absolutely fueled automobile parked and able to go) in impact by spending on two grids.
…
President Joe Biden is unlikely to take heed to such a proof and who is aware of if he would even perceive it. However actuality’s not going wherever.
Learn extra: https://www.wsj.com/articles/why-the-energy-transition-will-fail-11661547051
The Wall Avenue Journal additionally discusses the disparity in price between battery power storage vs a bulldozer assembled heap of coal.
Given the numbers so clearly point out renewable power is a non-starter, why do inexperienced advocates preserve claiming that the numbers add up?
The reply seems to be blind religion and optimism. The numbers don’t at present add up, however they anticipate costs to maintain falling, simply as costs have fallen over the past decade. From the United Nations;
Falling clear power prices present alternative to spice up local weather motion in COVID-19 restoration packages
10 JUN 2020 PRESS RELEASE ENERGY
…
The all-in, or levelized, price of electrical energy continues to fall for wind and photo voltaic, due to expertise enhancements, economies of scale and fierce competitors in auctions. Prices for electrical energy from new photo voltaic photovoltaic crops within the second half of 2019 had been 83 per cent decrease than a decade earlier.
…
“If governments reap the benefits of the ever-falling price ticket of renewables to place clear power on the coronary heart of COVID-19 financial restoration, they’ll take an enormous step in the direction of a wholesome pure world, which is the most effective insurance coverage coverage towards world pandemics,” Andersen mentioned.
…
These in any other case sensible individuals have drawn a pleasant curve on their graphs, the place they fitted the 83% price discount over the past decade. A few of them anticipate that exponential wanting curve to proceed indefinitely, giving us the “ever-falling price ticket of renewables”.
Moore’s regulation and renewable power
by Invoice Spindle | Jul 27, 2021
…
To this point, renewables have benefited from one thing akin to Moore’s Legislation –– as they grew exponentially, and received cheaper, inflicting sooner progress –– a virtuous cycle. As extra grid-scale battery storage comes on-line, offering stability for wind and solar energy, the batteries are additionally changing into cheaper.
The development has enticed a various array of entities to leap in –– from the conservative metropolis of Georgetown, Texas which sources 100% of its energy from renewable sources to tech large Microsoft Corp. aiming for carbon negativity by 2030 utilizing a mixture of renewable power and carbon elimination applied sciences.
However the path will not be as easy as targets and targets recommend. Not too long ago New York State officers unveiled a brand new aim of carbon neutrality by 2050, promising a very decarbonized electrical energy system. However shortly after, the New York Impartial Techniques Operator (NYISO), the physique chargeable for working the state’s power grid, issued a press release saying {that a} 70% renewable energy system by 2030 is “very achievable” however that attending to 100% renewable sources would require expertise that doesn’t but exist.
…
Learn extra (requires registration): https://www.climateandcapitalmedia.com/moores-law-and-renewable-energy/
One of many first issues I realized about statistics is extrapolation, extending the development line past the info, is dangerous. You’ll be able to match a naive development line to rising inventory costs, and extrapolation will inform you any time is an efficient time to purchase. The crash, when it happens, is an sudden departure from the naive extrapolated development.
But the individuals pushing renewable power, as a substitute of ready for the info to meet up with the development line, are pushing the whole world to gamble the way forward for all of us on their religion that the prices of renewable expertise can be “ever-falling”, will proceed to fall at a charge similar to the final decade.
And if the prices don’t fall in line with the plan – there may be at all times the choice of throwing infinite authorities cash at creating “expertise that doesn’t but exist”, David Attenborough’s Renewable Apollo Mission.
Think about 100 years from now. Future historians will certainly see this world gamble of trillions of {dollars} on “expertise which doesn’t but exist”, this blind religion in development traces, as an outbreak of mass hysteria they’ll wrestle to clarify.
Take into consideration the precise Apollo Mission. NASA didn’t dive straight into constructing the moon launcher, they constructed prototype after prototype, like Mission Mercury. Every prototype was a stepping stone, which offered learnings which made the following step potential.
Personally I’d favor to attend till the “expertise that doesn’t but exist” is developed, no less than to prototype stage, earlier than playing every thing on a inexperienced transition which possible isn’t potential.
