The altering face of Princes Road

Princes Road in Edinburgh is one in every of Scotland’s most iconic thoroughfares. It’s a favorite hang-out of locals and vacationers alike. Edinburgh’s primary business avenue runs alongside the southern perimeter of the New City Conservation Space. The north aspect of the road is dwelling to 43 buildings and a statue listed as nationally essential.

A sounding board

Though planning permission is granted or refused by the native authority planning departments and never by us, we’re typically consulted by native authorities on planning proposals that they assume are significantly essential. That is normally in relation to plans for Class A or B listed buildings. Yow will discover out about our position within the Scottish planning system.

It’s no shock, then, that over the previous few years, the Metropolis of Edinburgh Council has requested for our  recommendation on proposals to vary, prolong, reuse, and refurbish a lot of Princes Road’s iconic landmark buildings.

We’re at all times joyful to offer our view on a listed constructing consent utility. Our consultants be sure that the cultural significance of the buildings is known and supply our personal evaluation on the affect of proposals to change, prolong and alter these buildings.

The march of time

Princes Road has at all times modified. Over the a long time and centuries buildings have altered and tailored for brand new makes use of. In lots of situations, the need for greater inns, retail and business buildings resulted within the demolition of smaller buildings.

Right now, Princes Road has many layers of change following every era. The road began out as deliberate terraces of townhouses and tenements for the rich New City residents. This was outlined within the 1767 plan by James Craig.

This 1819 map by Robert Kirkwood reveals the Georgian elevations of Princes Road’s buildings and their gardens behind. Discover the map in additional element. ‘Reproduced with the permission of the Nationwide Library of Scotland’ (Attribution 4.0 Worldwide (CC BY 4.0).

Only a few of those stay and have been closely altered at floor and first flooring degree. Nonetheless, it’s possible you’ll spot the unique townhouse frontage on the higher ranges should you lookup.

Look as much as see Georgian townhouses lurking behind later additions to the road degree on Princes Road. ©HES

By the 1820s, the buildings had already began to vary. Companies started knocking by way of or altering the unique constructions to make outlets and inns.

Throughout the Victorian interval, many townhouses have been closely altered and prolonged. Bay home windows, further storeys, and entrance extensions to the bottom and first flooring have been all standard additions.  In some circumstances, the Georgian buildings have been demolished totally. An instance of that is the previous ‘Clarendon Lodge’ at 104-106 Princes Road. This was a big, purpose-built resort which till just lately housed Zara.

Are you being served?

Each Victorian and the Edwardian intervals noticed the introduction of big malls, corresponding to RW Forsyth which went on to turn into Topshop/Topman, and Jenners. This new period of consumption led to the constructing of towering structure and elaborately-carved stonework constructed to impress rich shoppers.

Forsyth’s spectacular and enormous constructing on the left. ©HES

Actually, Forsyth’s division retailer changed the short-lived Richmond Lodge, which was demolished after solely being there for 15 years! This reveals the impressively fast business turn-over of those areas. As well as, there have been additionally buildings constructed for others makes use of, like tearooms, member’s golf equipment, insurance coverage firm workplaces, banks, and the Image Theatre.

Princes Road meets the trendy age

Within the post-war period, modernist structure mixed with city planning concepts that Edinburgh ought to be remodeled to satisfy the expectations of the long run, and the calls for of elevated automobile possession.

In 1954, a panel of influential architects and city planners was fashioned to analyze how the road could possibly be improved. Reporting again in 1967, this group felt the road regarded messy with buildings of such diversified heights and kinds. Their plans would have seen many of the buildings on  Princes Road demolished and changed with new buildings designed to a unifying set of requirements. Solely three of the unique buildings would have escaped demolition, based on their designs.

A 1965 design for the Members’ Lounge at The New Membership (84-7 Princes Road). © HES (Reiach and Corridor Assortment).

This future-ready plan included placing a motorway alongside Princes Road, with a pedestrian walkway above. In fact none of this finally went forward. Nonetheless, there are a number of buildings with surviving key ‘Princes Road Panel’ options designed to suit into this future plan.

Boots (101-103 Princes Road) and the previous British Dwelling Shops constructing (64 Princes Road) are examples of buildings which characteristic a cantilevered overhang that might have linked to the elevated walkway at first flooring.

The BHS constructing, which contains thought from the ‘Princes Road Panel’ with it first flooring balcony. © HES

The alternative of a facelift

Throughout this era there have been additionally many circumstances the place buildings have been considerably rebuilt with solely the frontage remaining. This may be seen in pictures of the previous Conservative Membership (112 Princes Road) being transformed into the brand new Debenhams retailer (1978-81).

The constructing at 112 Princes Road is at present attributable to discover a new blended use as a resort, spa, restaurant, with retail on the bottom flooring. The historic frontage to Princes Road will as soon as once more be retained, carrying on this specific architectural custom.

Ringing the adjustments

These proposals for the previous Debenhams mirror the subsequent era of change, each inside our society and alongside Princes Road. The expansion of on-line purchasing and pandemic affect of extra dwelling working and fewer public commuting to town centre, has induced many outlets to shut or transfer. This, coupled with the opening of the brand new St James Quarter purchasing centre, has resulted in lots of big-name excessive avenue outlets relocating and leaving empty premises behind on Princes Road.

Plans afoot

Whereas there are some short-term outlets utilizing these models, many buildings at the moment are being processed by way of the planning system. A lot of the plans contain changing the buildings for blended use: particularly inns with bars and eating places at avenue degree.

We welcome sustainable reuse of Scotland’s historic buildings. The greenest constructing is one which already exists. Moreover, they’re more likely to lead to higher general upkeep of the properties alongside Princes Road.

Over time, lots of the buildings have had vacant higher flooring whereas the main target was on maximising retail flooring house on the decrease ranges. An absence of stairwells on higher flooring was additionally problematic when it got here to fireplace laws, as there weren’t sufficient escape routes. Sadly, these uncared for higher flooring have typically accelerated the chance of decay in lots of properties alongside Princes Road.

Nonetheless, the entire latest proposals we’ve got reviewed goal to restore and reinstate these higher flooring with improved entry. Utilizing the higher flooring implies that new stairs or lifts shall be put in to soundly get folks out and in. For us, this can be a optimistic end result, as folks will be capable to get pleasure from and inhabit these historic buildings for years to return and can proceed to benefit from the incredible views of Edinburgh Fort.

One of the vital high-profile renovation proposals on Princes Road is for the previous Jenners constructing. In January 2023 a deadly fireplace broke out within the former division retailer. Renovations are set to start once more following a police investigation into the hearth. Our consultants have been available to supply recommendation and assist round fireplace security in historic buildings. Our ideas proceed to be with the chums, household and colleagues of Barry Martin, the firefighter who died within the line of responsibility.

From homes to division retailer to vacationer attraction

Wanting on the West Finish nook (144-147 Princes Road) specifically, the location’s historical past is typical of Princes Road.

This web site was initially residential homes within the Georgian type. These have been extensively altered and transformed into the Osbourne Lodge round 1873, thereafter utilized by the Scottish Liberal Membership.

Within the Victorian interval, Robert Maule purchased the buildings. He transformed them to the Robert Maule & Co. division retailer.

In 1935, the shop was purchased over by Binns, a Yorkshire-based division retailer, which demolished and re-built the façades of the entrance constructing. This resulted within the Artwork Deco type which we recognise in the present day.

Home of Fraser, one other upmarket division retailer, purchased out Binns in 1953. Nonetheless, the shop continued buying and selling underneath the Binns title for a while. Curiously, sooner or later the constructing across the nook (3 Hope Road) was included into the location. A purpose-built Royal Financial institution of Scotland from 1930, it’s of comparable architectural styling. Nonetheless, you’ll be able to see that the peak of the flooring don’t fairly match as much as the join constructing on the nook.

A twenty first century expertise

In September 2021, the constructing was given a brand new lease of life by the Johnny Walker Expertise, changing into a brand new customer attraction for town. This noticed extra adjustments to the property, together with a brand new rooftop bar. These days, there was a want to situate bars and eating places on Edinburgh’s rooftops. These purposes are assessed on a case by case foundation by the native planning authority. The rooftop extension by the Johnnie Walker Expertise is a profitable instance. It doesn’t affect on the looks of the 1935 listed constructing, which initially had its roof hidden behind the frontage when seen from under. It’s actually the right spot to absorb fantastic views throughout the Waverley valley to the Fort!

The renovations carried out by Johnnie Walker, additionally included sympathetic restoration to the outside. One distinguished enchancment have been the repairs to the Nineteen Sixties clock which is a much-loved characteristic for locals and vacationers.

What subsequent?

Hopefully this romp by way of the fates and fortunes of Princes Road has highlighted how the road has at all times modified over time. With present stress of on-line purchasing and post-pandemic life, Edinburgh’s primary business avenue is shifting into a brand new part of improvement.

The Metropolis of Edinburgh planning division is more likely to see extra purposes coming in for reuse of the buildings on Princes Road. Keep in mind that the general public is at all times welcome to become involved on this course of.

Should you’re obsessed with Edinburgh’s constructed heritage, it’s at all times price protecting an eye fixed out for any future professionalposals. Because of the dimension of those buildings, many builders are required to seek the advice of on their redevelopment plans.

You may also:

If you’re within the regulatory requirements we apply in managing change to the historic setting, learn our sequence of non-statutory steerage notes on the way to apply the Historic Surroundings Coverage for Scotland.