By Robert Bradley Jr. — March 7, 2023
“ExxonMobil needs extra: an ‘preliminary’ enhance within the tax credit score to round $100 per metric ton (from $85) and an prolonged eligibility interval to 30 years (from 12 years). And ‘Present a $10 billion grant to assist develop infrastructure in Houston….’”
“Carbon seize and storage is a ‘loss chief’ for ExxonMobil to formally greenwash. For the Biden Administration, CCS is a bribe offering leverage on the most important vitality main.”
Yesterday’s submit described ExxonMobil’s abandonment of its biofuels (algae) enterprise, wildly uneconomic after greater than a decade of effort and lots of of hundreds of thousands of {dollars} invested. However the firm’s Low-Carbon Options division has one thing a lot greater in course of: Carbon Seize and Storage (CCS), marketed as “Offering business options wanted to assist scale back emissions through the vitality transition.” (Ouch! ExxonMobil endorsing “the vitality transition” away from its main merchandise, oil and fuel.)
Background
CC&S has a free-market aspect, one which makes use of CO2 for enhanced oil restoration. That labored for many years, no taxpayer or U.S. Division of Power required. However as we speak’s initiative isn’t placing the CO2 to work however burying it underground for non-use with a load of taxpayer and stockholder monies. A feel-good feat of engineering that destroys worth somewhat than creates it, from the patron/economic system viewpoint.
Subsidies for CC&S date again to the American Restoration and Reinvestment Act of 2009. [1] Totally different legal guidelines and IRS interpretations then created a tax credit score of as much as $45 per metric ton. Not sufficient, complained ExxonMobil and different rent-seekers. The Biden Administration stepped in with the ExxonMobil-supported Inflation Discount Act of 2022. Wrote Tim Mullaney in ESG Affect:
The important thing to the sudden flurry of [CC&S] exercise is the Inflation Discount Act…. The legislation elevated an current tax credit score for carbon seize to $85 a ton from $45, Goldman mentioned, which can save the Exxon/CF/Enlink venture as a lot as $80 million a yr. Credit for captured carbon used underground to reinforce manufacturing of extra fossil fuels are decrease, at $60 per ton.
However ExxonMobil now needs extra: an “preliminary” enhance within the tax credit score to round $100 per metric ton (from $85) and an prolonged eligibility interval to 30 years (from 12 years). And “Present a $10 billion grant to assist develop infrastructure in Houston by extending present U.S. Division of Power packages past analysis, growth and demonstration (RD&D).”
Right here is the pitch from Erik Oswald, ExxonMobil’s vp of technique and advocacy, Low Carbon Options (created April 2022):
- Insurance policies enacted when carbon seize and storage know-how was in its infancy at the moment are outdated and should be adjusted. For instance, the federal authorities has laws in place for extracting oil and pure fuel from beneath the floor, however none for injecting CO2 far beneath floor for secure, safe and everlasting storage.
- Insurance policies ought to help venture growth to encourage funding. Funding obtainable underneath the federal carbon seize and storage tax credit score needs to be expanded to supply help much like what’s obtainable to different low-carbon applied sciences, reminiscent of wind and photo voltaic. Guidelines needs to be adjusted to replicate the lengthy design and building phases of carbon seize and storage tasks.
- Governments can present monetary help to assist construct the required shared infrastructure, reminiscent of pipelines. As with different transportation infrastructure, like highways for instance, incentives reminiscent of direct loans, mortgage ensures and credit score help can present important help to large-scale carbon seize and storage growth.
And the outlined agenda of ExxonMobil in CC&S:
Improve the CCS Manufacturing Tax Credit score (45Q) for non-EOR (enhanced oil restoration)
- Initially enhance worth to ~$100 per metric ton from present $85
- Prolong eligibility interval to 30 years from present 12 years
- Remove deadline for beginning building
Guarantee authorities approval for CO2 storage
- Particularly permit offshore storage of CO2 from sources apart from coal
- Authorize the Bureau of Ocean Power Administration to concern leases, rights of manner and pore house
- Make clear that the U.S. Environmental Safety Company has authority for allowing CO2 injection in subsea formations
Present monetary help for CCS infrastructure
- Present a $10 billion grant to assist develop infrastructure in Houston by extending present U.S. Division of Power packages past analysis, growth and demonstration (RD&D)
- Develop the U.S. Division of Power Title XVII program to incorporate the deployment of current CCS applied sciences at scale
- Amend TIFIA (Transportation Infrastructure Finance and Innovation Act) so as to add CCS tasks, or create a program devoted to CCS
ExxonMobil states: “Now we have cumulatively captured extra CO2 than some other firm – 120 million metric tons – accounting for about 40 p.c of all of the anthropogenic CO2 that has ever been captured.” Properly, loads of this was for financial, not governmental, causes, growing oil restoration. It’s the political stuff that’s controversial to either side of the political debate.
Conclusion
Carbon seize and storage is a “loss chief” for ExxonMobil to formally greenwash. For the Biden Administration, CCS is a bribe offering leverage on the most important vitality main. The excellent news is to be discovered elsewhere, particularly CEO Darren Woods’s announcement that ExxonMobil will enhance oil and fuel manufacturing for so far as the attention can see.
ExxonMobil has dedicated $15 billion in CCS by 2027 with the prospect of extra. A few of this may be postponed attributable to opposition or diminished subsidies. Maybe some income might be recouped if EOR can usher in oil income. However it’s the taxpayer that’s on the hook to Huge Oil on this occasion. And XOM buyers should be asking some arduous questions on the subsequent annual shareholders assembly Could 25, 2023.
——————
[1] The 2009 Act backed CC&S as follows:
Investing in Carbon Seize and Sequestration.
One technique for limiting greenhouse fuel emissions is to stop the carbon launched by fossil gas combustion from coming into the ambiance. The Restoration Act offered $2.1 billion to help initiatives that vary from characterizing the carbon sequestration potential of geologic formations, to cost-sharing agreements to exhibit superior carbon seize and storage applied sciences for coal, together with:
Petra Nova – W.A. Parish Publish-Combustion CCS Sequestration venture: DOE offered $163 million in monetary help by the Clear Coal Energy Initiative (CCPI) Spherical 3, which incorporates funding from the Restoration Act. The Petra Nova venture, a three way partnership between NRG Power and JX Nippon Oil & Gasoline Exploration would be the first commercial-scale post-combustion carbon seize retrofit venture within the U.S.
As soon as accomplished, the vitality know-how venture will seize about 1.4 million metric tons of carbon dioxide (CO2) yearly from an current coal-fired energy plant in Texas, and the captured CO2 will then be used to extract further, hard-to-access oil from a beforehand depleted area 80 miles away. Development is anticipated to be accomplished in early 2017, and already there are solvent tanks, absorber sections, and the cogeneration unit in place.
Archer Daniels Midland (ADM) Industrial CCS Challenge: DOE awarded $141 million to ADM for the Illinois Industrial Carbon Seize and Storage venture, which demonstrates an built-in system for amassing carbon dioxide from an ethanol manufacturing plant and geologically sequestering it deep underground. ADM completed building on the venture and started operations in 2015. It is going to inject an estimated 900,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide a yr into the Mt. Simon Sandstone Reservoir – one of many largest and finest saline aquifers on this planet.
