Air Fryer Stuffed Mushrooms – Recipes From A Pantry

May 5, 2023

2

These Air Fryer Stuffed Mushrooms are easy to make and stuffed with taste! These prep-ahead bites are an ideal appetizer, celebration snack, or facet dish.

Appropriate for vegetarian and gluten free (with modifications) diets. Submit consists of Weight Watchers factors

Submit might comprise affiliate hyperlinks. For extra data, examine my disclosure

Mushroom lovers, rejoice as a result of these Air Fryer Stuffed Mushrooms are easy to make and completely scrumptious. Wealthy, earthy, meaty mushroom caps are loaded with a tacky, herby filling and air fried till the savory mushrooms are tender, the cheese is melty, and the breadcrumb topping is golden and crispy.

This traditional appetizer will get a contemporary improve while you cook dinner stuffed mushrooms in air fryer. They cook dinner rapidly, and the necessity for extra oil is eradicated. Plus, you’ll be able to simply customise the filling with some easy modifications to make this recipe low carb, keto, gluten free, vegetarian, and even vegan!

Yeap, this stuffed mushroom recipe makes a scrumptious snack, a flowery (but oh, so easy) appetizer, or a tasty meal when mixed with a salad. And if you would like much more scrumptious mushroom recipes, you’ll need to try this air fryer mushrooms recipe and these air fryer garlic mushroom steaks!

top down view of air fryer stuffed mushrooms on a white plate

Better of all, air fryer stuffed mushrooms might be ready 24 hours upfront. Get the mushrooms prepared, retailer within the fridge, and cook dinner simply earlier than serving. Good for dinner events, recreation day gatherings, potlucks, and anytime you’re entertaining.

Why Make This Recipe

Customizable – Use this recipe as a springboard and modify it to suit your style and dietary preferences. The cooking technique stays the identical.
Good for Advance Prep – Put together the filling and fill the mushroom caps as much as 24 hours upfront. Retailer them within the fridge till able to air fry the stuffed mushrooms.
Versatile – Function an appetizer in your favourite meal, or add a salad and bread to serve the mushrooms as a foremost dish.

Ingredient Notes

Mushrooms – Choose mushrooms with bigger cap sizes, akin to Child Bella mushrooms (Cremini). See the FAQs for recommendations on utilizing Portobello mushrooms.
Bread Crumbs – Use panko breadcrumbs for probably the most crunch. Substitute gluten free bread crumbs if desired, or depart them out altogether for a keto pleasant dish.
Parmesan – Freshly grated parmesan cheese tastes nice and melts properly.
Cream Cheese – Deliver common cream cheese to room temperature. Substitute low-fat cream cheese if desired.
Cheddar – Sharp cheddar brings a pleasant tanginess. Use gentle cheddar or your favourite shredded cheese.
Salsa – Add gentle salsa or marinara sauce for taste.
Ranch Seasoning – You possibly can measure from a packet of ranch dressing combine or search for the bigger containers which might be excellent for utilizing in recipes.
Dried Herbs – A contact of oregano, dried sage, or your favourite dried herb provides taste.
Salt and Black Pepper – Add kosher salt and floor pepper to style, substituting with garlic salt if most popular.

image collage showing some of the ingredients needed to make air fryer stuffed mushrooms

Able to discover ways to make the perfect stuffed mushrooms air fryer? Collect your elements, and I’ll present you…

How To Make Air Fryer Stuffed Mushrooms

Get the whole elements listing and directions from the recipe card beneath.

Deliver the cream cheese to room temperature.
Mix the softened cream cheese, cheddar cheese, half of the shredded parmesan cheese, salsa, and the seasoning in a small bowl. Mix till creamy and properly mixed.
Wipe the mushrooms clear with a humid paper towel and take away the stems, leaving the caps intact.
Evenly divide the cheese-filling combination between the mushroom caps.
Place the stuffed mushrooms in a single layer within the air fryer basket and bake for quarter-hour at 375 levels F / 190 levels C.
Whereas the mushrooms bake, mix the breadcrumbs and the remaining grated Parmesan cheese in a small bowl.
Open the air fryer and sprinkle the mushrooms with the breadcrumbs combination. Air fry for five extra minutes to crisp up the topping or till golden brown.

image collage showing the steps for making air fryer stuffed mushrooms

Skilled Ideas

You don’t want to grease the air fryer mushrooms, however spraying the air fryer basket with olive oil will stop the mushrooms from sticking to the tray.
You possibly can mix the filling by hand. Alternatively, you’ll be able to use a hand mixer or toss all the things right into a meals processor and pulse it a couple of instances till mixed.
I want to wipe the mushrooms with a humid material or paper towel to wash them however be at liberty to scrub them should you want.
Chop the mushroom stems and add them again into the filling combination or freeze them so as to add to soups or different recipes.
When you’ve got smaller mushrooms, you’ll be able to use a spoon to softly press down the gills to create a bigger cavity within the mushroom cap.
Don’t be afraid to pile on the filling.
Cook dinner mushrooms till they’re tender, including extra time as wanted.
When you’ve got any leftover filling, stir it into your scrambled eggs for a scrumptious breakfast.
Mushrooms shouldn’t be slimy. Discard any which might be slimy or have a fishy odor.
Air Fryer temperatures can differ relying on the make and mannequin, so use the cooking time listed as a information; examine for doneness and regulate cook dinner time as wanted.

top down view of the finished stuffed mushrooms in air fryer basket

Scrumptious Variations

Add Garlic – Garlic and mushrooms make an attractive match. Add minced garlic or garlic powder so as to add a heat, earthy taste.
Make it Vegetarian – Exchange the parmesan cheese with a vegetarian substitute.
Make It Low Carb/Gluten Free – Swap the breadcrumbs for floor almonds or gluten free breadcrumbs. Remove the bread crumbs to make this low carb.
Make It Vegan – Use vegan cheeses as a substitute of cream cheese, cheddar, and parmesan to make a vegan model of this recipe.
Swap The Spices – You possibly can swap out the dry spices in your favourite seasoning blends.
Swap The Cheeses – Use your favourite mix of cheeses. Fontina, gruyere, and swiss are glorious substitutes. You should utilize any comfortable cheese rather than cream cheese.
Add Veggies – Add caramelized onions, sauteed spinach, or your favourite cooked veggies to the filling combination.
Add Protein – Combine in cooked floor meat akin to floor sausage, floor beef, or floor turkey. It’s also possible to add diced bacon or diced shrimp.

a plate filled with air fryer stuffed mushrooms set on an orange placemat

Prep And Storage

Prep Forward – Prep and fill the mushroom caps as much as 24 hours upfront and retailer them on a tray coated in plastic wrap within the fridge till able to cook dinner.
Retailer – Leftover mushrooms will maintain for 2-3 days within the fridge saved in an hermetic container. Reheat for 3-5 minutes at 400 levels F / 204 levels C.
Freeze – Stuffed mushrooms are greatest made recent, however they are often frozen earlier than being cooked. Simply observe these steps:
- Assemble the mushrooms as directed and place them on a baking sheet.
- Flash freeze, then switch to a freezer bag for as much as 3 months.
- Cook dinner from frozen, including extra time as wanted till the mushrooms are cooked, and the cheese is melted.

the completed air fryer stuffed mushrooms recipe

FAQs

Can I Make Air Fryer Stuffed Portobello Mushrooms?

Sure! This recipe works nice for Portobello Mushrooms and makes a terrific meatless foremost dish. The filling will fill 2-3 further massive Portobello Mushroom caps, and the cooking instances would be the identical.

How Lengthy To Cook dinner Stuffed Mushrooms In Air Fryer?

Precise cooking instances can differ barely between manufacturers and types of air fryers. The mushrooms will cook dinner for about quarter-hour. Then you’ll add the topping and cook dinner for five minutes for a complete of 20 minutes. You may be on the lookout for the cheese to be comfortable and melty and the breadcrumb topping to be golden and crispy.

What Are The Greatest Mushrooms To Use For Stuffed Mushrooms?

For this recipe, it would be best to choose mushrooms with a bigger cap that may maintain the filling. White mushrooms or brown button mushrooms are available and make a great possibility. Our favourite mushroom is the Child Bellas for taste and measurement. It’s also possible to use the bigger portobello mushroom caps to serve this as a meal slightly than an appetizer.
Enjoyable Truth: Button, Child Bellas (cremini mushrooms) and portobello mushrooms are the identical number of mushrooms at completely different phases of development!

a plate of air fryer stuffed mushrooms served garnished with thyme

Extra Recipes You Might Like

Serving Options

close up view of the completed air fryer stuffed mushrooms

Weight Watchers Factors

There are 8 Blue Plan SmartPoints in a single serving of this.

Thanks for studying my stuffed mushrooms in air fryer recipe publish. And please come go to once more as I proceed to slice, cube, and dream up reasonably priced Air Fryer recipes, On the spot Pot Recipes, Southern Recipes, and extra. Thanks for supporting Recipes from a Pantry, meals weblog.

Get The Stuffed Mushrooms Air Fryer Recipe:

Don’t overlook to tag #recipesfromapantry on Instagram or Twitter should you strive Air Fryer Stuffed Mushrooms! It’s actually, actually superior for me while you make one among my recipes and I’d like to see it. It’s also possible to share it on my Fb web page. Please pin this recipe to Pinterest too! Thanks for studying Recipes from a Pantry.

Print Recipe