“The buried years are gone! — however I stay.
The world hath aged grown; — however I’m younger,
Nonetheless younger in agony, which fiercer grows,
Because the sluggish weary flapping wing of weary Time
Drags closely onward. — Thy soul-searing curse, […]”From The Loss of life of Cain in Dramas of the Historical World
by David Lyndsay
Mary Diana Dods, David Lyndsay, and Walter Sholto Douglas have been considered three totally different individuals till 1991, when literary tutorial Betty T Bennett uncovered their story in “Mary Diana Dods, A gentleman and a Scholar”.
Walter’s story is exceptionally distinctive. One which needs to be recognised for what it was, not what it could possibly be. Contemplating the extraordinary effort it took to create Walter, I understood it as my obligation to consult with them with the identification they have been final recognized for. I take advantage of he/him and so they/them to consult with Walter.
Walter Sholto Douglas, christened Mary Diana Dods 1790, was raised alongside their sister Georgina Douglas within the Dalmahoy Home, the seat of their father, George Douglas, the sixteenth Earl of Morton.
It’s assumed that each siblings have been of illegitimate nature, which doubtless performed a task of their relocation to London to keep away from scandal.
© Courtesy of HES. This can be a photographic copy of an engraving of Dalmahoy Home. Zoom in on Canmore
By 1810, their father had married, and Georgina married and moved to India, leaving Walter to their very own gadgets. Letters from each siblings give us a flavour of the household dynamic. They recommend their father provided little assist, financially or in any other case, and that Walter may need lived with a incapacity.
The age of the nom de plume
By 1821, Walter, nonetheless often known as ”Mary”, begins to submit translated works and compositions underneath the identify of “David Lyndsay”.
Nameless submissions have been a preferred pattern of the 18th century and comparatively unquestioned. Writers of all genders and skills submitted work with a nom de plume, and Walter adopted swimsuit.
“I typically, about as soon as 1 / 4, write a criticism for the Reviewers upon some common work, any that occur to be the style, for which, I’m esteem’d one of many cleverest and keenest of that race of Vipers.
“I’m paid tolerably effectively, ten Guineas per sheet, however this not underneath my very own identify I dare not acknowledge the Truth lest the offended Authors whose works I’m compelled to maul in the midst of my vocation ought to return the praise and maul me in return.”
M D Dods, letter to Lord Morton, 26 June 1822
Walter presents a real purpose for writing underneath a male pen identify, nevertheless it doesn’t really feel prefer it was the one purpose. As “David”, they submitted many works for publication, together with essays, tales and translations – not simply critics. Why did Walter downplay his success?
“It might be absurd to say something in the best way of reward to the Writer of such scenes, for the thoughts that was able to conceiving and so admirably executing them, should take heed to its personal powers, and really feel that the world should do them justice.”
William Blackwood in a letter to David Lyndsay, 3 January 1822
This speaks volumes of the the integrity and clever work Walter created underneath the identify of “David Lyndsay”. His work was so admired, that “David” was invited by the respected Blackwood Journal to submit work as a part of “Collections of Dramas” in late 1821.
© Michael TRB Turnbull. Licensor www.scran.ac.uk This can be a Nineteenth-century plan of William Blackwood’s store in 45 George Road, Edinburgh
Sadly although, it didn’t promote in addition to Blackwood hoped. “David” continues to submit work to magazines together with Blackwood’s, nevertheless, issues decelerate by 1823. Some assume that Blackwood refused them work following the frustration of the sale, however I don’t agree. In letters to Blackwood, “David” mentions that they have been ailing with liver illness, explaining why they have been struggling to submit work on time which could have been a distinct purpose.
‘So splendidly intelligent and so queer trying’
“David” and Blackwood proceed to trade letters for years, sharing skilled and private information. Shocking information even, corresponding to “David” becoming a member of literature societies in London and befriending revered writers, one being Mary Shelley, the writer of “Frankenstein or, The Fashionable Prometheus”.
Walter did enter these circles however underneath “Mary Diana Dods”, the identify they’d been christened with – a girl with no prestigious household identify, or fortune. I actually surprise how they joined these circles with out the success they’d constructed underneath their pen identify.
The Scottish author and pal of Mary Shelley, Eliza Rennie, give us a flavour of what may need been:
Definitely Nature, in any of its wildest vagaries, by no means customary something extra grotesque-looking than this Miss Dods.
She was a girl apparently between thirty and forty years of age, with a cropped curly head of brief, thick hair, extra resembling that of a person than of a girl.
She wore no cap, and also you nearly fancied, on first taking a look at her, that some one of many masculine gender had indulged within the freak of female habiliments, and that “Miss Dods” was an alias for Mr. —.
She had . . . a complexion extraordinarily pale and unhealthy, with that worn and struggling look in her face which so typically and so really—because it did, poor factor, in hers—tells of ordinary ache and confirmed ill-health; her determine was brief, and, as an alternative of being in proportion, was completely out of all proportion—the existence of some natural illness aiding this materially.
Her gown, by its singularity, accorded effectively together with her bodily peculiarities and disqualifications, and solely tended to intensify and exasperate, so to talk, the oddity of her tout ensemble. She was habited thus: —Her gown was of some white material—cambric, I feel—and although the style of the interval sanctioned “gores,” and robes have been then, hers was of such a really lean description, that it had one thing the resemblance of a close-fitting pillow-case. On it was a row of little successive tucks, which reached to the knee, as if to have physique and skirt of 1 materials was of too bizarre a personality for her toilette.
Eliza Rennie in “Traits of Character; Being Twenty-5 Years’ Literary and Private Recollections”
“Doddy’s” dressing model assumed them as a person in drag somewhat than a girl in drag. This can be a telling story in itself.
A wedding of comfort?
Isabella Robinson, a pregnant, single girl of 17 years of age, enters Shelley’s and Walter’s social circle. We don’t know a lot about Isabella, besides she was married to Walter!
Let’s ponder right here for a minute. Isabella was in want of a father for her youngster, however have been they in love too?
Shelley performed an enormous half in serving to Walter and Isabella journey to France. She employed two actors with bodily similarities and helped them forge signatures and create authorized passports to move as husband and the spouse of Walter Sholto Douglas.
Mary Shelley – a pal or a lover?
“Doddy’s” suave persona and mind gained many over. However how did they change into such shut buddies with Mary Shelley?
Eliza Rennie, describes her first impression of “Doddy” and their relation to Mary Shelley:
The appeal and fascination of her method, the extraordinary expertise which her dialog, with out pedantry or pretence, displayed, quickly reconciled me to all of the singularities of her look, and checked all inclination to mirth; and I rapidly ceased to surprise at “Doddy,” as she was familiarly termed by Mrs. Shelley and her intimate buddies, being so especial a favorite. She was an amazing linguist, being totally versed in nearly each European language, and, taken collectively, an individual of very outstanding psychological endowments.”
Eliza Rennie in “Traits of Character; Being Twenty-5 Years’ Literary and Private Recollections”
We do know that Walter did reveal their pen identify “David Lyndsay” to Mary Shelley. Not solely that, however Shelley helped unfold the phrase about “David’s” sensible writing and inspired publishers to take their work.
In a letter Mary Shelley signifies that she had been romantically concerned with a girl, possibly additionally bodily:
“Ten years in the past I used to be so prepared to provide myself away—& being afraid of males, I used to be apt to get tousy-mousy for girls.”
I can’t assist however really feel intrigued by Walter’s reference to Shelley. This friendship fashioned rapidly and have become outstanding in each of their lives. With out Shelley, Walter wouldn’t be recognized by this identify at present.
© Nationwide Portrait Gallery, London. Oil on canvas of Mary Shelley by Richard Rothwell
Climbing the patriarchal ladder
Some speculate that “Mary” wished to climb the patriarchal ladder and acquire recognition as a author.
We all know it was exhausting for feminine writers to be taken significantly – it resonates a lot with how historical past was instructed. However why one other identify change? “David Lyndsay” was a superb identify and one they’d constructed a popularity with already. If all Walter wished was to hitch necessary societies in France and discover a good submit, then bringing “David” to life would have been a real win. In spite of everything, this persona existed for years and held respect in literature circles.
Walter had an opportunity to be “Mary Diana Dods”. Shelley was their approach out of the hidden life and the nom de plume, and into recognition as one of many few feminine writers of the time. Let’s not neglect that Shelley did too begin with a pen identify, and it was modified to Mary Shelley as soon as her work was recognised. Why didn’t ‘Dods’ do the identical if climbing the patriarchal ladder was all they ever wished?
“In a way, ‘Mary Diana Dods’ is a minimum of as false a reputation as ‘Walter Sholto Douglas’ for ‘Douglas,’ the household identify of the Earls of Morton, reveals a real blood relationship, the paternity that the identify of Dods was designed to cover.”
Betty T Bennett in “Mary Diana Dods, A gentleman and a Scholar”
© Christie’s Pictures / Bridgeman Pictures
Portrait (oil on canvas) of George Douglas, sixteenth Earl of Morton, son of Sholto Douglas, fifteenth Earl of Morton, and father of Walter and his sister Georgina.
The final chapter of Walter Sholto Douglas
There are mentions of Walter becoming a member of the “French Anglo society” and forming connections with writers and politicians throughout their time in France. Sadly, nevertheless, it didn’t get them far based on Shelley’s letters. With mentions of his bodily and psychological well being deteriorating, Isabella, younger with a baby, and monetary struggles, Walter was challenged immensely to “make it” into this world.
We do see them again on the pages of Blackwood Journal round 1828 – underneath the identify of “Walter Sholto Douglas”, however that didn’t appear to get them very far both.
Seemingly, the life-long money owed ultimately caught up with Walter.
In a letter, despatched from a debtors’ jail in November 1829, Walter pleads to have a moustache and masc gear despatched to him.
This request brings despair and crippling anxiousness to my coronary heart.
I can’t and I don’t wish to think about what it was like for Walter to be with male inmates, attempting to cover the “female” facets of their physique in an surroundings the place privateness is non-existent.
There are not any data of their demise, trigger, or perhaps a date. One would assume their physique was examined and “discovered”?
No, they merely disappeared off of the planet.
Nobody questioned it.
none.
That’s our lives’ value.
Queer lives.
We come ourselves and we disappear for simply that…
Simply
That.
Forgotten.
Individuals grief us in silence.
Strangled souls
Staining each breath, we take
The assassin lives…
Lives
Lives
Loves
Within the shadow of its judgement
Relaxation in peace Walter.
Concerning the Writer
Adam Kashmiry is an award-winning, neuro-divergent, Egyptian-born, Glaswegian-raised Performer, Story-teller, Eexperimental Mover & Author, and a Queer Activist.
Kashmiry is a certified Hypnotherapist and his life’s ardour is decoding and understanding the language of the unconscious, and growing a apply that depends closely on understanding interior challenges and experiences with somatic motion, compassion in the direction of oneself, launch and heal. Observe him on insta
Have you ever heard about Lavender Menace, Scotland’s first ever LGBT+ bookshop? Or do you wish to dig into our Transient Timeline of LGBT+ Historical past in Scotland? – Discover extra tales from Scotland’s LGBT+ Historical past on our weblog.
