Baking trays are a helpful help when popping issues in and eradicating them from the oven. Whether or not you’re rigorously pouring custard into your custard tart or lemon filling into your lemon tart, a baking tray positioned beneath your tart tin presents some a lot wanted stability.
Oven trays can take a bashing, as oil residue and typically charred stays construct up over time. We predict it’s greatest to have a few baking trays; one or two that you simply hold particularly for these extra delicate baking duties, making certain you get the right batch each time, and a number of for on a regular basis objects, like pizzas, chips, fish fingers.
Extra like this
The baking trays on this record vary in value from a few kilos as much as £45+. For some, baking trays are one thing you’ll use on a regular basis, so we expect it’s value paying a bit of extra for one thing sturdy, dependable and well-made.
This information is commonly up to date with new baking trays which were tried, examined and top-rated by BBC Good Meals’s opinions specialists. These that includes earned their place primarily based on their efficiency throughout rigorous, neutral product testing, any baking trays that warped throughout check had been immediately disqualified. Included is a choice of new baking trays in addition to favourites that constantly maintain their place in opposition to the newer trays. We are going to solely ever characteristic baking trays that show to be good worth for cash.
Go to our opinions part and uncover greater than 600 sensible patrons’ guides providing unbiased recommendation on what tools is value investing in. Discover every thing from counter-top home equipment such because the greatest stand mixers and greatest air-fryers, via to smaller important package just like the greatest cake tins and the greatest non-stick frying pans.
Soar to:
Finest baking trays at a look
- Finest baking tray for eco credentials: Mermaid Silver Anodised baking tray, £25
- Finest baking tray for top cooking temperatures: Le Creuset Ovenware giant tray, £42
- Finest baking tray for giant trays: Nordic Ware Naturals sheet pan, £14.38
- Finest baking sheet: Le Creuset Insulated cookie sheet, £74.99
- Finest heavy responsibility baking tray: Netherton Foundry Heavy Obligation baking sheet, £45.95
- Finest baking tray set: Tala 3-piece baking tray set, £17.60
- Finest shallow baking tray: Zyliss non-stick carbon metal baking tray, £18
- Finest finances baking tray: Masterclass non-stick baking tray, £6.99
- Finest vibrant baking tray: Status x Nadiya baking tray, £24.99 for a set of two
- Finest glass baking tray: Pyrex Bake & Get pleasure from glass multipurpose baking tray, £18.49
Finest baking trays 2023
Mermaid Silver Anodised baking tray
Execs:
- Accessible in three sizes
- Made within the UK
- Completely baked cookies
- Sustainably made
- Lifetime assure
Cons:
Finest baking tray for eco credentials
Star score: 5/5
This engaging and light-weight aluminium baking tray from Samuel Groves is offered in three sizes: 12, 14 and 16 inches. We notably beloved this tray for its spectacular eco credentials. Not solely is it made within the UK, but it surely additionally comes wrapped in totally recyclable packaging and has a lifetime assure.
It’s oven protected as much as 230C and will also be used on ceramic, gasoline and electrical hobs, making it best for gravies. It will also be used underneath the grill.
Regardless of being on the sunshine aspect, this tray is remarkably sturdy. The edges of the tray are tall and gently curved, making it simple to take away from the oven.
Our check cookies unfold gently within the oven and baked evenly high to backside. As soon as baked they got here off the tray with complete ease.
Key specs
- Materials: Silver anodised aluminium
- Sizes out there: 30.5cm, 35.5cm, 40.6cm
- Dishwasher protected: No
- Assure: Lifetime
Le Creuset Ovenware giant tray
Execs:
- Generously sized
- Engaging
- Sturdy
- Oven protected to a excessive temperatures
Cons:
Finest baking tray for top cooking temperatures
Star score: 5/5
Created from exhausting anodised aluminium, it is a sturdy, well-made tray. It’s oven protected as much as 260C, which is likely one of the highest temperatures of all of the baking trays on this record.
We beloved the slim, sculpted handles at both finish of the baking tray. Though they’re small, they’re simple to grip and make placing objects in and eradicating them from the oven a doddle. They’re additionally embossed, which is a modern completion.
Not solely is that this tray immune to a excessive temperature, but it surely’s additionally dishwasher-safe, freezer protected and can be utilized underneath the grill.
After 10 minutes of cooking, the cookies had been evenly baked and nicely browned each on the highest and backside. They unfold barely, however remained tender and gooey inside. The cookies got here off the tray simply too.
Key specs
- Materials: Arduous anodised solid aluminium
- Sizes out there: 28cm, 35cm
- Dishwasher protected: Sure
- Assure: Lifetime
Accessible from Le Creuset (£42)
Nordic Ware Naturals sheet pan
Execs:
- Is available in good vary of sizes
- Notably light-weight
- Very sturdy
Cons:
Finest baking tray for giant trays
Star score: 5/5
Nordic Ware is probably greatest identified for its high-quality, extremely sturdy bundt tins, however the baking trays are equally nearly as good.
This one is notably light-weight, however sturdy and well-built, with tall barely sloping sides. They’re out there in a very good vary of sizes, together with the biggest sized baking tray of all of the trays on this record: a half sheet – 43cm x 31cm.
Our cookies baked to perfection utilizing this tray. They unfold gently and had been crisp and evenly browned high and backside. There was no sticking when eradicating them from the tray both.
These trays are oven protected as much as 230C, however Nordic Ware recommends in opposition to dishwashing as this may trigger the pan to discolour.
Key specs
- Materials: Aluminium
- Sizes out there: 25cm, 33cm, 40cm, 43cm
- Dishwasher protected: Not really helpful
- Assure: Lifetime
Le Creuset Insulated cookie sheet
Execs:
- Lifetime assure
- Double-walled
- Toughened non-stick
Cons:
Finest baking sheet
Star score: 5/5
This sturdy, shiny black carbon-steel cookie sheet comes with an extra-toughened non-stick floor, making it tremendous easy. Coupled with the flat edges, cookies slide gracefully from the sheet with out assist.
We love the orange heat-resistant silicone inserts, not just because they make transferring the new sheet round safer, however in addition they assist the sheet stand out within the drawer or cabinet.
Our cookies browned shortly on the double-walled sheet, however had been darkish within the really helpful 10 minutes. Future bakes had been eliminated at 8 minutes, ensuing within the excellent color and snap. We love that with only a fast wipe, the sheet is pristine.
The Le Creuset is a roomy 38cm, can stand up to temperatures as much as 240C, and comes with a lifetime assure – however we doubt you’ll ever must name that in.
Key specs
- Materials: Non-stick coated carbon metal
- Sizes out there: 38cm
- Dishwasher protected: No
- Assure: Lifetime
Netherton Foundry Heavy Obligation baking sheet
Execs:
- Ought to final eternally with care
- Straightforward to carry
Cons:
Finest heavy responsibility baking tray
Star score: 5/5
This hand-forged 2mm-thick black metal sheet from Shropshire-based Netherton Foundry is the sturdiest and heaviest (1.9kg) sheet in our check. It is oven-safe as much as to 300C.
In the event you can deal with a little bit of weight, the sheet will serve you nicely, because it heats up very quickly, is evenly unfold, and bakes cookies in 8 minutes with a good color and sharp, crisp snap.
Regardless of the load, the Netherton sheet is likely one of the best to carry out and in of the oven, because it has a cleverly designed 2cm stepped rim on one aspect.
The sheet makes use of no chemical compounds or PTFE. It is pre-seasoned with flax oil, making it naturally non-stick. This therapy can (and should) be repeated every so often.
Nevertheless, the sheet may even tackle the oils and fat out of your bakes, creating a stunning patina over time that may solely get extra lovely with age. A wipe is all that’s wanted to maintain the sheet clear.
Key specs
- Materials: Black iron
- Sizes out there: 33cm, 44cm
- Dishwasher protected: No
- Assure: One 12 months
Accessible from Netherton Foundry (£45.95)
Tala 3-piece baking tray set
Execs:
- Nest properly for straightforward storage
- Good dimension multipack
- Sturdy trays
- Oven protected to excessive temperature
- Made within the UK
Cons:
- Very thick – cookies cooked slowly
Finest baking tray set
Star score: 4.5/5
In the event you’re typically cooking for quite a lot of individuals or identical to to have the choice of a few totally different sized trays, this Tala set, that includes two 25 x 18 cm trays and one 34.5 x 24.4 tray, is a superb alternative.
The trays are sturdy, a deep black and really easy. Our baked cookies slid off the tray leaving nothing behind.
Every tray is fairly versatile too. Not solely are they oven protected to 240C however they’re additionally freezer, dishwasher and grill protected. We had been additionally impressed to see that these trays include a 10-year guarantee and, as a heritage model, have continued manufacturing within the UK too.
Our cookies had been ever-so-slightly slower to bake when utilizing these trays, which left our cookies trying thicker and a minute underbaked.
Key specs
- Materials: Carbon metal
- Sizes out there: 12cm, 25cm, 34.5cm, 39.5cm, 40cm
- Dishwasher protected: Sure
- Assure: 10 12 months
Zyliss non-stick carbon metal baking tray
Execs:
- Engaging blue design
- Sturdy and nicely constructed
- Strengthened sides
- Spectacular non-stick
Cons:
- Just one dimension out there
- No overhang to grip
Finest shallow baking tray
Rating: 4.5/5
This baking tray from Zyliss has one of many slickest non-stick surfaces of all of the trays we examined: nothing caught.
It’s engaging in design, with a deep blue non-stick coating, and is remarkably sturdy and sturdy. For ease, it’s oven protected to 240C and can be dishwasher protected, although it’s extremely unlikely this tray will must be cleaned in a dishwasher.
The oil slick-like floor did imply that our cookies unfold a bit of additional than we’d have preferred, however this tray left them evenly baked and evenly browned high and backside.
Our solely slight gripes with this tray are that it’s solely out there in a single dimension (39.19 x 26.7 x 2.49 cm) and there aren’t any lips for straightforward insertion or removing from the oven.
Key specs
- Materials: Carbon metal
- Sizes out there: 39cm
- Dishwasher protected: Sure
- Assure: 5 years
Accessible from Zyliss (£18)
Masterclass non-stick baking tray
Execs:
- Dishwasher and freezer protected
- Sturdy
- Spectacular non-stick coating
- Accessible in a very good vary of sizes
Cons:
Finest finances baking tray
Rating: 4.5/5
Easy, understated and fuss-free, this Masterclass baking tray doesn’t include all of the nifty design-features of a number of the different trays on this record, relatively it’s simply been designed to get the job finished.
Created from carbon metal, this baking tray is tremendous sturdy. We noticed no warping after we positioned it within the oven and our cookies unfold gently and baked to perfection. Though the non-stick floor is a much less easy than the Zyliss above, our cookies had been simple to take away from the tray.
This tray is each dishwasher and freezer protected, however we had been let down by the quantity of non-recyclable packaging included.
Key specs
- Materials: Carbon metal
- Sizes out there: 10cm, 24cm, 26cm, 35cm, 39cm
- Dishwasher protected: Sure
- Assure: 20 12 months (5 on non-stick)
Status x Nadiya baking tray set
Execs:
- Vibrant design
- Sturdy
- Inside measurements on tray
Cons:
- Trellis design on base not for everybody
Finest vibrant baking tray
Rating: 4.5/5
As probably the most vibrant baking trays on the record, these ones actually stood out amongst the group. These baking trays are a part of a wider assortment by Status and Nadiya Hussain and all objects are available in the identical teal colourway.
Like most of the different trays on this record, these trays are comprised of carbon metal, so are sturdy and durable. For simple clear up, they’re additionally dishwasher protected.
Our cookies baked very well on these trays, browning evenly throughout and that includes a crisp base. We did discover the distinctive trellis sample baked onto the bottom of the cookies. While this was a cute contact that might be best for one thing like a roulade, we felt that this may increasingly not at all times be appropriate or the specified end for various meals.
Key specs
- Materials: Carbon metal
- Sizes out there: 34.4cm, 39.5cm
- Dishwasher protected: Sure
- Assure: 10 years
Pyrex Bake & Get pleasure from glass multipurpose baking tray
Execs:
- Is available in vary of sizes
- Straightforward to wash
- Freezer, dishwasher and microwave protected
Cons:
- Fairly shallow
- Quick assure
Finest glass baking tray
Rating: 4.5/5
Well-known for his or her super-strong glass merchandise, this Pyrex baking tray is a formidable choice if you happen to’re after one thing versatile. Like most of the different baking trays on this record, it’s dishwasher protected and freezer protected, however distinctive to glass trays, this one can be microwave protected too.
It’s out there in simply two sizes and it’s oven protected to 220C.
We additionally rated this tray for its eco credentials; not solely is glass simple to recycle, however the tray got here with only a paper insert and is made within the UK.
While glass is of course non-stick, it’s slower to warmth up than metallic, so our cookies required a couple of minutes longer within the oven in comparison with the opposite trays on this record. However they unfold gently and had been properly browned throughout.
Key specs
- Materials: Borosilicate Pyrex glass
- Sizes out there: 24cm, 32cm
- Dishwasher protected: Sure
- Assure: Two years
Different baking trays examined and rated by BBC Good Meals specialists
- Salter Champagne baking tray, £9.99
- Progress Shimmer non-stick baking tray, £8.99
- Circulon Ultimum insulated baking sheet, £21.99
- Choose non-stick baking sheet, £22
- Stellar/James Martin Bakers Assortment non-stick baking tray, £9
How to decide on a baking tray
Though it’s tempting to purchase an affordable baking tray, we didn’t need to fall foul of the false economic system. Shopping for a tray that may final for years saves cash and problem in the long term, however we had been eager to attempt each cheaper manufacturers and extra high-end merchandise to discover a product to swimsuit everybody’s wants.
In the event you’re a frequent baker, 10-year or lifetime ensures are interesting, because it offers you the information you could depend on your baking sheet time and time once more. For many who bake much less incessantly, a finances choice that also presents affordable high quality would possibly really feel like a greater spend.
A very good-quality non-stick floor will guarantee no pesky baked-on remnants. We regarded for trays which have such an efficient non-stick coating that it would not be crucial to use butter, oil, liners, parchment or foil.
The baking trays on this record are manufactured from quite a lot of supplies. It’s value remembering that totally different supplies present totally different cooking outcomes.
Glass: Sensible at conducting and holding onto warmth, however is a bit of sluggish to warmth up. It’s heavy-duty and is an eco-conscious alternative.
Carbon metal: Light-weight, naturally non-stick and extremely sturdy. Carbon metal is stronger than aluminium and is a superb, long-lasting warmth conductor. It’s inclined to rust, nonetheless.
Aluminium: Each fast to return to temperature and to chill down. Meals usually browns evenly and it’s a light-weight and inexpensive choice. While it’s immune to corrosion, it may react to acidic meals.
Chrome steel: Arduous-wearing, sturdy and long-lasting, chrome steel is reasonable in addition to non-reactive and protected from corrosion and rust. It may well distribute warmth inconsistently although.
Methods to clear baking trays
As with all cookware, baking trays must be washed after every use to maintain them in tip high form.
To make sure the longevity of the non-stick, we advocate hand-washing. Although we recognise that life is busy and typically you merely don’t have the time to face over a sink scrubbing away, so, if the baking tray permits, sometimes popping it via the dishwasher is completely tremendous.
For baking trays that are not dishwasher protected, however have an enormous construct up of roasting juices or burned bits, pop the baking tray within the sink, fill it with washing up liquid and simply boiled water and permit it to sit down. As soon as the water has cooled, any caught on bits ought to have loosened or risen to the highest, permitting you to go in together with your sponge or material to wash all of them off.
A reusable various to parchment paper or tin foil are silicone baking mats. Our pals at olive examined and reviewed a complete vary to seek out the greatest silicone baking mats.
How we examined baking trays
We reviewed a consultant pattern of practically 30 baking trays and scored them in opposition to the next standards.
Sturdiness: We regarded for a tray that was sturdy sufficient to resist excessive heats with out buckling or twisting.
Weight: A very good, sturdy tray won’t ever be too mild that the tray feels flimsy, as the load of stable supplies retain and evenly distribute the warmth, all of which helps the bake. Nevertheless, if too heavy to begin with, as soon as laden with cookies or pastries it will likely be tough to hold. We regarded for trays that sat comfortably someplace between the 2.
Non-stick: A very good-quality non-stick floor that may stand the check of time, without having for extra oiling or using liners, parchment or foil, if potential.
Ease of use/practicality: A lip, handles or shallow sides for transferring the tray round with our treasured bakes was essential.
Dishwasher or hand-wash: Each are good, however given washing in a dishwasher destroys the non-stick floor over time, we preferred trays that wanted little greater than a wipe to maintain clear.
Sustainability: We regarded for trays comprised of sustainable supplies, baking trays with lengthy or lifetime warranties scored extremely too, as did these packaged in totally recyclable supplies.
Testing methodology:
We put all of the trays via their paces utilizing our basic classic chocolate chip cookie recipe, dolloping the biscuit combine immediately onto the tray. All of the sheets and trays examined will also be used for pastries, bread and scones as nicely. The deeper trays are additionally good for roasting, the place little or no oil is required.
Discover out extra about how testing works at BBC Good Meals by heading over to our how we check web page.
Associated opinions
Finest spatulas
Finest flour shakers
Finest pastry brushes
Finest icing turntables
Finest marble rolling pins
Finest measuring units
Finest piping baggage
Finest cooling racks
Finest rolling pins
Baking tray recipes
Greek lamb traybake
Cherry choc and coconut traybake
Italian broccoli and salmon bake
Pancetta-wrapped fish with lemony potatoes
Apricot shortbread
Spiced aubergine bake
Tiramisu meringue roulade
When you have any questions or strategies for future opinions, or spot something that has modified in value or availability, please get in contact at goodfoodwebsite@fast.co.uk.
